Genetic diversity gives honeybees an edge

Worker bees from more genetically diverse hives are more capable of dealing with day-to-day tasks.Social insects like ants, bees and wasps are some of the most successful animals on the planet. By acting as large super-organisms, they can achieve things that larger singular creatures cannot.

Their astounding selflessness is driven by an unusual way of handing down their genes, which means that females actually have more genes in common with their sisters than they do with their own daughters. And that makes them more likely to put the good of their colony sisters over their own reproductive legacy.

The more related the workers are to each other, the more willing they will be to co-operate. So you might expect colonies of social insects with fairly low genetic diversity to fare best. But that’s not the case, and Heather Matilla from Cornell University has found that exactly the opposite is true for bees.

Bee queens will often mate with several males (a strategy called polyandry). It’s an unexpected tactic, for it means that the queen’s daughters will be more genetically diverse and slightly less related to each other than they would be if they all shared the same father. And that could mean that selfless co-operation becomes less likely.

Despite this potential pitfall, social insect queens do frequently sleep with many males, and all species of honey bee do this. There must be some benefit, and Mattila has found it. Together with Thomas Seeley, she showed that a genetically diverse colony is actually a more productive and a stronger one.

New colonies

Most new colonies fail to survive the winter.For a honeybee, setting up a new colony is a difficult business. It starts when the fertile queen sets off with a swarm of several thousand infertile workers to establish a new nest. From the moment they do this, the clock is ticking.

Before the harsh conditions of winter sets in, they need to build a hive, collect food reserves and replace their ageing workforce with fresh workers, all from scratch. If they’re inefficient, the colony will die of starvation in the winter cold and, indeed, 80% of colonies perish in this way.

To test the effect of genetic diversity on efficiency, Mattila and Seeley artificially inseminated 21 queens with the sperm of either a single male drone or fifteen different ones. The queens were relocated to a blank hive in early June, together with almost 8,000 of her daughter workers, and watched.

Competitive advantage

Two weeks later, the genetically diverse colonies were already out-competing and out-producing their genetically narrow counterparts. They expanded their hives (in terms of comb area) by 20% more, collected up to 78% more food and they built up 39% larger reserves of food. And all this was done with almost exactly the same number of workers – they just worked harder and faster.

The more efficient colonies made better use of a time of plenty, when collectable food was freely available. And by the end of August, they had reared so many more young that their workforce was five times larger than their dawdling rivals.

Honeybee colonies are more productive if they are more genetically diverse.Their success not only gave them a competitive advantage – it ensured their survival. In late August, a cold period killed about half of the single-father colonies and by December, they were all dead. But the multi-father ones all pulled through the autumn cold and 25% made it past the winter freeze.

With such better results, it’s no surprise that the queens of so many social insect species mate with multiple males. There would be intense natural selection for this strategy, and it would spread extremely quickly through the bee populations.

Why is diversity better?

But one important question remains: why are the genetically diverse colonies more efficient? Mattila and Seeley point to previous research, which shows that a worker’s genes strongly affect the probability that they will take on certain tasks around the hive.

For example, workers start to ventilate the hive when it gets too hot and their genes set their internal thermostat, determining what each workers thinks is ‘too hot’. A genetically narrow workforces risks not responding at all to changes in temperature or to over-respond, with the entire hive involved.

In contrast, a genetically diverse workforce would have a broad range of critical temperatures, and be able to respond more appropriately to subtle heating and cooling patterns in the hive.

During times of hardship, it’s more likely that the hive will have plenty of workers with the genetic background to cope with it. And in times of plenty, a larger proportion of workers will be willing to take advantage of new resources.

More on bees and other insects:
Beetle and yeast vs. bee – how American bees are losing the evolutionary arms race
Butterflies evolve resistance to male-killing bacteria in record time
Aphids defend themselves with chemical bombs
Army ants plug potholes with their own bodies

More on animal genetics:
When the heat is on, male dragons become female
Chimerism, or How a marmoset’s sperm is really his brother’s
Chimps have more adaptive genetic changes than humans

Reference: Mattila & Seeley. 2007. Genetic diversity in honey bee colonies enhances productivity and fitness. Science 317: 362-364

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,


4 Responses

  1. Those survival rates seem really low. I assume the 80 percent dying over the winter refers to wild colonies? But doesn’t 75 percent loss of the experimental colonies seem high?

    In what conditions were the experimental colonies kept? I realize they wouldn’t be fed or medicated. Are honeybees so fragile now that they pretty much can’t survive without human help?

  2. do honeybees camouflage themselves I really need to know be Feb.27 at 2:00

  3. Hello!
    Very Interesting post! Thank you for such interesting resource!
    PS: Sorry for my bad english, I’v just started to learn this language 😉
    See you!
    Your, Raiul Baztepo

  4. Hi !! 🙂
    I am Piter Kokoniz. oOnly want to tell, that your blog is really cool
    And want to ask you: will you continue to post in this blog in future?
    Sorry for my bad english:)
    Thank you:)
    Piter Kokoniz, from Latvia

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: